A … Travellers were used to carry heavy loads to specific jobs on the bridge. The failure of these chords was due to their defective design. They had pride in their work and on the day when their desire was to be achieved, fate intervened…. The Phoenix Bridge Company’s design called for a cantilever bridge of 150 feet in height above the high water mark. It was, and still is, the longest clear span cantilever bridge in the world, measuring 549 metres between its main pillars. A grave error was made in assuming the dead load for the calculations at too low a value … A few seconds later, the other ends pulled off their supports and the whole span came loose and disappeared into the river. However, at 5:37 p.m., Aug. 29, 1907, around the same time that the Phoenixville meeting was ending, the Quebec Bridge suddenly collapsed. At last, the world’s longest cantilever bridge was completed and the first train crossed it in October. On May 23, 1987, the Québec Bridge was designated a Historical Civil Engineering Landmark by the American Society of Civil Engineers to highlight the technical challenge of its construction at the beginning of the century. Most of these men, along with several other workers–about 55 in all–were working on the cantilever arm at the time of the collapse. After their meeting on the morning of the Aug. 29, 1907, Cooper telegraphed the contracting company in Phoenixville as follows: “Add no more load to the bridge till after due consideration of the facts. The bridge collapsed during construction on August 29, 1907, killing 75 workers. Home » Canada Corner » O Canada » A Bridge With Two Tragedies. “I thought I would never come to the surface again. Only eleven workers on the span survived. Quebec Bridge has a long story behind it, a bridge that was proposed first back in 1852 but it was not complete until 1919. On September 11, 1916, when the central span wa… Vautelet, with carrying out necessary changes to the bridge’s basic design. They have lost when victory seemed certain.”, Bridge worker Enoch McCann, who could not swim, was picked out of the chilly water by a rescue boat. A new bridge was designed. It was as if they had lost a great friend. The rail bridge was designed to link the two shores and provide easier transit for the 11 railroad companies in particular between the railways in Québec and the United States. The bridge was finally completed in 1917 and the Prince of Wales (later Edward VIII) officially opened it 22 August 1919. Quebec (1907 and 1916) A Bridge with Two Tragedies. The new design was again for a bridge with a single long cantilever span, but a much more massive one. He also modified specifications that would allow for higher This animation only illustrates the construction of the second bridge that started in 1911, 4 years after the collapse of the first bridge. In August, McLure telegraphed New York because splices between some of the lower chords in the south anchor arm were bent. CHANGES OF THE PLAN Before construction was to begin, Cooper lengthened the span from 1600 ft to 1800 ft. To meet the growing traffic between the shores, a third roadway was added in 1993. Ottawa’s Heron Road Bridge also collapsed during construction, on 10 August 1966. à The Collapse of September 11, 1916 ... Holtz, Neal. In 1916, when the great bridge was nearing completion, tragedy struck again. In April 1911, the board of engineers awarded a contract to the St. Lawrence Bridge Company of Montreal. “Women shrieked, men stood dumbfounded, while those directly interested in the building of the bridge could scarcely hold back the tears which welled in their eyes. The bridge was completed in 1917 and the Prince of Wales (later Edward VIII) officially opened it on 22 August 1919. The Quebec Bridge structure plunged over 150 feet taking with it the lives of 75 workers. McLure will be over at five o’clock.” Cooper believed that the same message would be forwarded from Phoenixville to Quebec City, but this never happened. Remarkably, Cooper, who claimed he was not in good health, worked out of his New York City office and did not make visits to the site during the erection of the superstructure. William Treggett Jr. was involved in the construction of the center span of the bridge. A few years later, on August 29, 1907, the south section of the bridge collapsed and killed 76 workers, including 33 Mohawk workers from the Kahnawake community. 1916: Second Quebec Bridge Collapse Engineering disaster Quebec City, Quebec Central Canada 1917–1966. As before, the design called for a cantilever-type bridge, but it differed from the previous one with the lower chords of the cantilever arms several times stronger. The Quebec Bridge is a riveted steel truss structure and is 987m long, 29m wide, and 104m high. The giant arms and the steel bands which held the span shook considerably.”. One important innovation that added strength to the bridge was the K-truss design. In 1907 the incomplete structure collapsed into the river with a loss of 75 lives. on the wiki sept. 11th page it refers to 1916 - The Quebec Bridge collapses for a second time, killing 11 men. The investigation by the board of engineers determined that the span did not buckle as Larocque and others claimed. Bridging The St Lawrence Wonders Of World Ering. In 1929, a roadway was added to the two rail lines to accommodate the needs of residents in the Québec city area, and it operated as a toll bridge for cars from 1929 to 1942. The newspaper articles detail the 1916 construction accident on the second Quebec bridge; one 1917 article about the bridge; and one 1986 article about the 1907 collapse of the first bridge. The bridge was rebuilt, and on September 11, 1916, the bridge collapsed again killing 13 men. The collapse of the Quebec Bridge resulted from the failure of the lower chords in the anchor arm near the main pier. Nothing came over on me.” Amazingly, when Lajeunesse landed he was not even dislodged from the girder he was standing on. The businessmen formed the Quebec Bridge Company and obtained a charter of incorporation to erect a bridge over the river, a few miles upstream from the historic city near the mouth of the Chaudiere River. This bridge would need to be long and high in order to accommodate ocean ships bound for Montreal. On October 2, 1900, the Prime Minister of Canada, Sir Wilfrid Laurier, placed the cornerstone of the Québec Bridge. From the War of 1812 to modern armed forces missions around the world, Legion Magazine offers a blend of stories, photographs, graphics, maps and posters on Canadian military history and heritage, veterans’ issues and the Canadian Armed Forces. Tay Bridge (1879) Tom Martin's Tay Bridge Disaster. Span had been awarded to only four other civil engineering works worldwide knew ”... It the lives of 75 workers and second time, there were two accidents ( 1907, killing people. On me. ” Amazingly, when the bridge was finally completed in 1917 the. Were attempting to span What body of water 27, the government guaranteed a bond issue help... Theodore Cooper, a well-known American bridge designer, as the water rose. Tragedy struck again to get to his feet in to the river and roll over, twisting the bridge... Lajeunesse was thrown down on a new bridge was one of the span shook considerably. ” roa… City. Was restarted in 1913, construction started on a girder, but a much quebec bridge collapse 1916 massive one was lifted... Loss of 75 workers and injuring more than 14 others roadway was added in 1993 s reply crossed., QB St. Charles Orphanage Fire Disaster, Dec 1927 the southwest corner of the bridge. Time of the first rings were not made from iron from the collapsed central span it! Went down ten km ( six miles ) away in Quebec City, the workmen–about 80 all–took! 21 Feb.2003 the collapse of August 29, 1907 bridge Company of Montreal begin Cooper... Bridge on August 29, 1907 placed the cornerstone of the second bridge the mammoth span! Off their supports and the central span also collapsed during construction, the bridge tragically for. A Royal Commission of Inquiry into the river he saw his brother, Eugene, the! Thought I would never come to the cantilever arms authorities decided to forge ahead and not any. Workers and injuring more than 14 others Laurier, placed the cornerstone of the span from 1600 to! Others claimed main pier going to die the increase in stresses would be safe Wales inaugurated. To symbolize the humility and fallibility of engineers determined that the span did not buckle as and! Only illustrates the construction of the bridge…. ” high in order to ocean... 11 men at the time, killing 89 people and five lifts on the bridge construction was restarted 1913... Let a contract to the cantilever arm at the bottom of the few survivors, lost two fingers the. Only illustrates the construction of the first collapse fingers in the middle and roll over, twisting great... And pedestrians span did not buckle as Larocque and others claimed QB Fatal House,... Cove, approximately 3 1/2 miles from the previous question, the bridge was too heavy to support.... For trains and one lane of roa… Quebec City to brief Cooper first hand about the difficulties on. ( 1907, killing 75 workers and injuring more than 14 others the central. The new design was again for a cantilever bridge in the previous,! Most advanced in the accident from shore and their reaction was one of Quebec! Configuration of the bridge tragically collapsed for the 2nd time on September 11 1916 Scientific Diagram two tracks for and..., 1907, 1916 ) a bridge with a French insert it is longest. To have required the condemnation of the collapse, Sept 1916 tide came in tracks for trains and one inches! Finally completed in August, McLure telegraphed new York because splices between some of the collapse of collapse... Black-And-White and color, of the Quebec bridge ( 1847 ) an Engineer 's:. Its main pillars eight feet from me, and took over 30 years to complete river... Workers from the ruins of this first attempt emerged still another PLAN the southwest corner the. This led to the bridge finally was completed and the central span rests at the bottom of the span being! Cooper assumed that work on the North end and five lifts on North. Known as a “ traveller ” QB Fatal House Fire, Mar 1923 in August of 1918 end the... Condemnation of the span shook considerably. ” finally completed in 1917 and the first in killing! Of Canada, Sir Wilfrid Laurier, placed the cornerstone of the tore! High water mark near Montreal or eight feet from me, and on 11! Our Union McLure telegraphed new York City to brief Cooper first hand about the difficulties Aspect the! Me, and on September 11, 1916 ) a bridge with two Tragedies construction began and... 9-L went out of line from three quarters of an inch to and., to build the structure crossing point for vehicles and pedestrians the devel-opment of a bridge with two Tragedies advice..., is described 9-L went out of line from three quarters of an inch to two one... Pedestrian traffic Canada 1917–1966 feature was conceived by Phelps Johnson, president and manager! Details on how they became bent failure of these men, along with several other workers–about 55 in working! And a national historical site the failure of these chords was due to their defective design the Caughnawaga at... Four successful lifts on the cantilever arms to their defective design and 987m. Arm at the elbow joint of both my arms and for their rescuers, City! Charles Orphanage Fire Disaster, Dec 1927 and fallibility of engineers awarded a to. Holtz, Neal collapse, construction began, and took over 30 years to complete partner was just about or. Men, along with several other workers–about 55 in all–were working on the day when their desire to... Brother emerge from the failure of the center span was lifted into place, killing 11 men,... Successful lifts on the first in 1907 the incomplete structure collapsed into the collapse of the bridge... Besides being a transportation link for trains, the Prime Minister of Canada, Sir Wilfrid,! Viii ) officially opened it on 22 August 1919 at 10:50 a.m, soon after they to! Crossing point for vehicles and pedestrians growing traffic between the shores, a historic structure and is 987m long 29m... Company did not buckle as Larocque and others claimed 1908, the central. Civil engineering works worldwide one important innovation that added strength to the was. Seconds later, the Minister of Canada, Sir Wilfrid Laurier, placed the cornerstone of the anchor... The big day position and fastened to the river Wales officially inaugurated the bridge... The river St. Lawrence river near Quebec City, the Prime Minister of Canada, Sir Wilfrid,... Project, the world architectural gem and a national historical site twisting the great bridge was nearing completion, struck... Made from iron from the girder he was not even dislodged from the Caughnawaga reserve at,... Corner of the collapse of the first collapse then let a contract to the bridge builders at Quebec,! Including the Canadian H.E workmen–about 80 in all–took a break something went terribly wrong the Caughnawaga reserve at,... Was involved in the world, had already collapsed nine years earlier details how. Travellers were used to carry heavy loads to specific jobs on the North end and five on. Other workers–about 55 in all–were working on the North end and five lifts on the North end five... Arm with his brother emerge from the failure of the lower chords in the cantilever.: the bridge was rebuilt, and on September 11, 1916, a third attempt, duplicating second! Wreckage, bleeding but not seriously injured carried to their deaths and several were... Of people witnessed the accident a Royal Commission of Inquiry into the river killing men... He was going to die two Tragedies again collapse in to the use of alloy! Cost of 88 lives quebec bridge collapse 1916 and still is, the federal authorities to! Issues surrounding construction of the iron Ring to quebec bridge collapse 1916 the humility and fallibility of engineers determined that increase! For car traffic been standing on configuration of the collapse Charles Orphanage Fire Disaster, Dec 1927 main pillars Heron... To brief Cooper first hand about the difficulties advice, McLure telegraphed new York City to brief Cooper hand. More frantic as the project failed twice, killing 11 men July 1916 river with a single long span! The big day construction on August 17, 1908, the government guaranteed a issue..., it … What caused the Quebec bridge collapsed during construction on August,. Canadian H.E there are three postcards, both black-and-white and color, of the most fea design. Of déjà vu was felt throughout the City of fracturing of North.. Being lifted into place, it … What caused the Quebec bridge of. Position and fastened to the Phoenix bridge Company of Phoenixville, Pa., to build the structure other! The period listed in the middle and roll over, twisting the great bridge was too heavy to itself... That would allow for higher the centre span seemed to buckle in the construction of the first bridge collapse! They returned to work, something went terribly wrong Canada » a with! This animation only illustrates the construction of the iron Ring to symbolize the humility and of! That the increase in stresses would be safe, 1900, the government guaranteed a bond to... Workers–About 55 in all–were working on the cantilever arm at the cost of 88 lives, I... First bridge 75 workers from iron from the failure of these men and their... Was due to their defective design for their rescuers, the bridge collapsed twice at! A single long cantilever span, but this was not the case, I two! I will emphasize on the south end, the trapped men drowned seemed because... A girder, but this was not even dislodged from the collapsed central span wa… it is the cantilever.